Commissioners urge PM to stop police mega-forces

A stock image of a group of uniformed police officers pictured from behind during the day. There are all wearing hi-vis vests with the word "police" printed on the back. They are all wearing blue plastic gloves, and one office has a pair of handcuffs in his belt. Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,

Commissioners for Thames Valley, Hampshire and the Isle of Wight, and Dorset have signed a letter warning against creating police "mega-forces"

ByStuart Rust
South of England
  • Published

Police and crime commissioners (PCCs) across the South have joined others in urging the Prime Minister to scrap plans for new "mega-forces".

The commissioners for Thames Valley, Hampshire and the Isle of Wight, and Dorset are among PCCs to sign a letter, which warns there is no evidence bigger forces perform better, and that merging them could mean council tax rises for millions of households.

The government plans to cut the number of police forces in England and Wales from 43, with reports suggesting it could fall to nine.

This month, Met Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley proposed between eight and 10 regional forces, warning the current system was "heading for failure" without reform.

Hampshire police and crime commissioner Donna Jones in a posed shot. She has long blond hair and blue eyes and is wearing a dark blue coat. She is stood in a large field and some out-of-focus trees can be seen in the background.Image source, Hampshire PCC
Image caption,

Hampshire PCC Donna Jones says one chief constable could be responsible for an area stretching from Essex to the New Forest

Hampshire PCC Donna Jones said that if forces were cut to nine, a single chief constable would be responsible for an area stretching "from the border of Essex to the edge of the New Forest, and from the southern tip of the Isle of Wight to Milton Keynes".

"That geographical area is far too big for any chief constable to truly understand," she said.

The letter, dated 13 November and addressed to Andy Burnham, was signed by 29 police and crime commissioners and two deputy mayors for policing. It calls on him to "urgently intervene to stop the forced mergers of police forces".

While the PCCs accept there may be a case for voluntary mergers where there is public support, they say mergers "should not be imposed top down".

The letter also warns that cutting forces to nine would push up council tax for millions, as the police share of bills would have to be brought into line.

Matthew Barber, a man with short dark hair wearing a blue suit jacket over a pink shirt, is stood by a country road during the daytime. The road is lines with green trees on either side.
Image caption,

Thames Valley PCC Matthew Barber says bigger police forces do not automatically mean better policing

Thames Valley PCC Matthew Barber said: "Bigger police forces do not automatically mean better policing. I have consistently argued that the real issue is not force boundaries, but the way policing is funded."

Surveys by the commissioners in the Thames Valley and Hampshire found more than 70% of those who took part opposed mergers, although they were open to anyone in the country and so not representative of all residents.

Dorset PCC David Sidwick has previously said the key to cutting crime "isn't size - it's leadership". He accused some large forces of trying to "load the dice in their favour".

But Rowley has argued that merging forces would cut duplication and free up thousands of roles for frontline policing.

"We have 43 overstretched forces trying to do too much, with too little," he said.

Responding to the letter, a Home Office spokesperson said the current model of policing "has not changed since the 1960s and is no longer fit for purpose".

A white haired man looks at the camera whilst stood in a scrap yard with twisted metal and heavy machinery behind him. He wears a shirt and tie and a shite high-viz vest
Image caption,

Dorset PCC David Sidwick has previously said the key to cutting crime "isn't size - it's leadership".

They said reforms would deliver "strong local policing focused on neighbourhood crime", alongside forces with specialist capabilities and a National Police Service.

A review of force structures by Lord Hogan-Howe has been handed to ministers but not published, and the Home Office said it would respond in due course.

Police and crime commissioners are due to be abolished in May 2028, with their powers passing to mayors where possible.

Get in touch

Your Voice